Sunday, November 15, 2026

The Last Time

Nancy Hale (1908–1988)
From American Flash Fiction: An Anthology

“Ask the Laceys to dinner, will you? We can all eat up here in your room.” Illustration by American artist Kirk Wilson (1912–1971) for “The Last Time” when it appeared in the October 1938 issue of Redbook.
The following item, which appeared on the front page of the Charlottesville Daily Progress on September 10, 1938, might strike many readers as less than ideal publicity for an up-and-coming author:
Wertenbaker’s Wife Writes in Hospital

“Last Time,” appearing in the current issue of Red Book, was written by Mrs. Charles Wertenbaker while she was a patient in the University Hospital for several months, it was learned today.

The story, dealing with the birth of a child to a society woman, whose husband is anxious for her to return from confinement to the “gay life,” closely parallels that of Mrs. Wertenbaker, who writes under the pen name of Nancy Hale. A woman of great versatility and wide interests, Mrs. Wertenbaker, who has a new son, recently left for Gloucester, Mass., to visit her family.
For months, the Daily Progress had been reporting on the travails of this literary New England woman, an outsider and divorcée who three years earlier had married into a locally prominent Charlottesville family. In February, the couple welcomed a son to their family—his first, her second. In May, the newspaper announced that she entered the hospital for an undefined illness (what polite company referred to nervous exhaustion) and, after emerging again in early September, she returned north to visit with her mother, the highly regarded portraitist Lilian Westcott Hale. Only two weeks after the article quoted above, the Daily Progress reported that Mrs. Wertenbaker was back in the hospital again for a “brief rest.”

Seven years earlier, in 1931, Charles C. Wertenbaker had arrived in New York for a job at Time magazine and was soon promoted to contributing editor at its sister magazine Fortune. Thirty years old, he had already published two novels (both scandalous satires of college life), and that year his first collection of short stories appeared. Hale, seven years his junior, moved to New York in 1928, initially worked on the staff at Vogue, and began steadily publishing stories and sketches in The New Yorker, Redbook, and Scribner’s. The couple married in 1935 and moved the following year to Charlottesville to be near Charles’s family—yet he often return to New York for his career as a journalist while Hale became a prolific, full-time writer of short stories. In 1941, after several periods of illness and separation, Hale and Wertenbaker ended what had been a rocky marriage.

By the time of her hospitalization in 1938, Hale had published two novels and an acclaimed story collection, The Earliest Dreams, and she was under contract for a third novel that she struggled to write. Her editor at Charles Scribner’s Sons, Maxwell Perkins, wrote to offer encouragement:
[If] you get discouraged it is not a bad sign, but a good one. If you think you are not doing it well, you are thinking the way real novelists do. I never knew one who did not feel greatly discouraged at times, and some get desperate, and I have always found that to be a good symptom. Anyhow, I have seen enough of the novel to have no anxieties about the outcome, but rather the very greatest hopes.
That novel, The Prodigal Women, was a 700-page, million-selling succès de scandale when it was finally published in 1942; it spent 23 weeks on the New York Times Best Sellers list.

“The Prodigal Women attracted attention with its daring revelations about the significantly shifting role of women during the 1920s and the 1930s,” writes Hale’s granddaughter Norah Hardin Lind. The novel “interwove the freedoms of the period’s New Woman with the structures that they were replacing, which did not simply cease to exist when women emerged from the kitchen.” For much of her fiction, Hale uncompromisingly mined her own successful career years (in 1934 she became the first female news reporter for The New York Times), her troubled marriages and emotional breakdowns, and her upbringing in a family of famous artists and writers. Similarly, “The Last Time,” which appeared in Redbook with the tagline “A short short story of a moment in a woman’s life,” depicts the conflicts between what tradition expects of her as a mother, what modern society expects of her as a woman, and what her husband expects of her as his wife—and what she might want for herself.

Note: Georges Braque (1882–1963) was a French painter associated with fauvism and cubism

*   *   *
For this week’s selection, we reproduce Hale’s story in its entirety below. You may also download it as a PDF or view it in Google Docs.

The Last Time

It was four-thirty in the afternoon. The leaded casement windows of their apartment let in a clear, late sunlight. Her husband moved about the room in a suit made of Glen Urquhart plaid, moving the things on the mantel, hanging a Braque reproduction in a silver frame.

“Besides, it ruins your figure,” he said positively, hanging the picture.

“Yes, dear,” she said obediently from the bed where she still lay, the silver bed with swans at the corners. Her swan’s-down bed-jacket was as if down from those very swans, and her hair was attractively dressed. She had lipstick on her mouth—the alluring young wife and mother, the happy young wife and mother.

It was four-thirty in the afternoon. An hour and a half till six. “Darling,” her husband said, pulling down his a-little-too-tight coat, “ask the Laceys for dinner, will you? And the Byrnes. We can all eat up here in your room so you won’t be lonely.”

Lonely, she thought, lonely with Him, Him in the next room! . . .

“Yes, dear,” she said again.

“I’m going down to Long Island for a bit,” he said, smoothing his hair. “And really, dear, I think you should make this the last time, because it will ruin your figure, and we sha’n’t be able to go anywhere; and besides, a nursing mother—you know what I mean.”

“I think you’re quite right,” she said stoutly from the silver bed. “It does mess you up, and take up so much of your time, and besides—”

Her husband reached for his Homburg hat and leaned over the silver bed to kiss his wife. His face was very smooth and smelled of shaving lotion, just as his hair did of hair-tonic. A tiny glossy lock fell forward as he leaned, and he straightened up and smoothed the whole glittering mass back into place.

He went away. An English maid took his place, and for some time there were orders to give. They were fun, those orders, about the rearrangement of rooms since she had come home from the hospital, about the clothes that she was going to wear with such élan. French clothes, swanky American-made clothes, clothes in sets and clothes that complemented each other. Her mother had been buying them for her since she had been in bed; with her famous flair, her mother had picked out the little black dress for afternoon, the little gay tweed suits for morning, those floating, candy-colored dresses for the evening.

It was going to be fun to wear those clothes. With her husband she would go to race-meets in the tweeds, to cocktail-parties in the little dresses, to dinners on Long Island in the long dresses like smears of pastel.

They knew a lot of people. Not just one kind of people. They knew Long Island people, and certain Westchester people, and quantities of foreigners to fill in at dinners, besides the clever New York people who did things—writers and lyricists and musicians and fashionable painters, people with names, big people; knowing them was something in itself. They knew people who lived in modernistic apartments, all different kinds of wood, and in amusingly Victorian apartments with bunches of dried flowers under glass on the mantelpiece, and in superb houses that made no attempt at mannerisms but were just grand in the grand manner—Persian rugs, framed oil-paintings, over-stuffed massive furniture. They knew every kind of person in every kind of house that was worth knowing.

And there was nothing very odd about that. Leaving her husband, who was so very presentable, out of it entirely, she was enough to attract the people that had been attracted. She had a charm of her own, people said. She had dark red hair, and dead white skin, and surprised green eyes. She was a beauty, in the biggest league. Her funny little mind (people called it) produced unexpected and delightful remarks. She danced like a dream, of course. She had entertained foreign visiting royalty so that it was really entertained, and difficult temperamental song-writers of great repute, and some of those odd writers who made so little sense and wrote you up afterward. Only she was always the heroine. She was the cream of the cream of desirability, with a husband, rich as a mine, so obviously mad about her, and the better section of the world at her feet.

*     *     *
She rode like a female centaur, of course. (These consoling thoughts were passing through her head as she lay in bed.) She swam in the water like a long white streak. She skied, at St. Anton and St. Sauveur. She fished for, and caught, tarpon. She shot at Thomasville and dragged at Aiken and hunted at Middleburg. Of money there was never any end.

Now, look, what she had to look forward to: Next month they were sailing for the Mediterranean, to be gone a month at the Lido. There were several adorers, not oppressive enough to be upsetting, who had lasted through this little maternal affair, and whom she could count on to follow her about like pretty staghounds. There were several diverting dinners to be gone to, several to be given, that would take time, and even for a woman with her money, planning. She had a white morocco book in which were written the names of desirable guests, plans for tables, and she would lie in bed of a morning and plan those dinners. She would lie in bed of a morning and—

Well! It was nearing six o’clock, and she could hear stirring about in the next room. A little wail. . . . Something in her trembled, but that was silly, because there was the best of English nurses, so much better than she herself, to look after the baby. And besides, when would she have had the time to look after a baby? Hadn’t she just been thinking of all the things that did, that must, fill her life? Let there be no more nonsense, then.

There was a movement in the doorway, and the English nanny appeared, bearing a certain pink-wrapped burden.

There was a definite technique to this business. The tiny thing was laid at your side; your nipple was washed with boric acid. The infinitesimal mouth reached eagerly, aimlessly for what it needed. The thing was really silly. It had no brains. It could not function. . . . Later, it would. They would send it to St. Paul’s, in time. But that would be much later. In the meantime it would be properly taken care of by the proper people, as should be. She, the mother, would see that everything was being properly done. But her own part in the business was definitely over. That was obvious. She wasn’t a cow; she was a busy, brilliant woman.

*     *     *
The little mouth found its objective and clung, sucking. It was curious, the pleasure in that sensation. Peasant mothers probably felt it. It was something not in her life, except for this little while it had been. The nurse moved out of the room, and she was left alone with her son. He was very small. The top of his head was all she could see, and the top of his nose, working as he sucked. It had been fun, hadn’t it, playing at being a real functioning mother for these few days?

Her arm tightened around the tiny lump within it. This was the last time; of course, there had to be a last time, for some one like her. That was the way she wanted it. He would take all sorts of lessons in things, and learn things, and go to the best schools, and some day he would take her out to lunch, his mother, like a young man escorting an only very little older woman. Wouldn’t that be nice?

She felt those little lips pulling at her body, pulling, sucking. . . .

“Good-by, my darling,” she murmured. Her eyes were drowned in tears. What made her say that?

First published in Redbook (October 1938).

Sunday, November 8, 2026

The Kiss

Kate Chopin (1850–1904)
From Kate Chopin: Complete Novels & Stories

Between Wealth and Love (Entre la richesse et l'amour), 1869, oil on canvas [cropped] by the French painter William-Adolphe Bouguereau (1825–1905). Wikimedia Commons.
The “rediscovery” of Kate Chopin’s novels and stories a half century ago arrived with numerous myths about how and why they had been neglected in the first place. Most prominent among them were the beliefs that her novel The Awakening had been widely banned upon its publication in 1899 and that the hullaballoo surrounding it probably contributed to the cancellation of the contract for what would have been her final book, the story collection A Vocation and a Voice. The book’s demise, biographer Per Seyersted speculated, may have convinced Chopin that “she had become a literary outcast.” She continued writing and publishing stories, but her output dwindled as her health declined, and she died at the age of fifty-four in August 1904.

Although The Awakening was certainly greeted with numerous condemnatory notices upon its publication, scholars have since discovered little evidence that Chopin was “banned” in any significant measure. In fact, only two incidents have been found, and both occurred three years after the book was published: the public library in Evanson, Illinois, and a private library in her hometown of St. Louis each removed the book from its shelves after some patrons objected to it. (Our introduction to Chopin’s story “Fedora” discusses the novel’s reception in greater detail.)

As for Kate Chopin’s third story collection, we may never know for certain why it was not published. In 1898 Chopin had sold the book, along with The Awakening, to the Chicago firm of Way & Williams, which had published her previous story collection, A Night in Arcadie. Unfortunately, that same year the company closed its doors and the existing inventory was sold to another publisher, Herbert Stone & Company, which “assumed no obligation to complete Way & Williams’ contracts for future publications.” Nevertheless, Stone agreed to publish The Awakening, and it was issued in April 1900. While by no means a top seller for the firm, the book’s sales seems to have met expectations; by the end of the year Chopin’s royalties totaled $102—more than the combined sum earned by her two previous books. Sidney Kramer, the company’s historian, suggests that there was at least one reprint. When Stone & Company itself ceased operations in 1905, the novel was even reissued by another publisher shortly after Chopin’s death.

Yet in February 1900 the manuscript for A Vocation and a Voice was returned to her. Any correspondence that might have accompanied the book has not survived, but literary historian Charles Johanningsmeier suggests an explanation: just days earlier, on January 26, 1900, Way & Williams assigned all their copyrights to the Doubleday, McClure Company in New York. Within months, however, Doubleday, McClure dissolved into two companies: Doubleday, Page and McClure, Philips. In other words, Stone, who was in the process of scaling down his own list, might not have “cancelled” the contract simply because he had never negotiated one for this collection, and it is possible that Chopin’s contract was overlooked or abandoned in the transfer of licenses for Way & Williams’s publications during a chaotic period of corporate restructuring. Perhaps discouraged by this chain of events, Chopin herself does not seem to have pursued publication of the collection with Doubleday, McClure or its spinoffs or any other publisher.

The book would have been a notable departure for Chopin, whose two previous collections were of stories mostly set among the Creole communities of Louisiana. When Penguin Classics finally published it in 1991, biographer Emily Toth noted in the introduction, “Kate Chopin abandoned Louisiana as a setting and local color as a mode of expression.” The stories, twenty-two in all, are far more experimental and impressionistic than her earlier work, and nine of them had appeared in Vogue, which during the 1890s published Chopin’s tales when they were too avant-garde or socially transgressive for mainstream publications.

A Vocation and a Voice includes the previous Story of the Week selections “Fedora,” “Her Letters,” and “A Morning Walk,” and below we present “The Kiss,” one of the pieces that had appeared in Vogue. “The tale mocks women who deny true love and passion for money,” writes Heidi Johnsen in an essay about Chopin’s writings for Vogue. “The magazine thrived on readers having an interest in the upper class, and yet Chopin laughs at them when she has Nathalie play the fool.” Choosing between money and love was the stuff of English and American literature from Jane Austen to Henry James, of course. “What is new, however,” notes Seyersted, “is the author’s amoral, detached attitude toward infidelity, and the wonderful light touch with which she ends such a story.”

*   *   *
For this week’s selection, we reproduce Chopin’s story in its entirety below. You may also download it as a PDF or view it in Google Docs.

The Kiss

It was still quite light out of doors, but inside with the curtains drawn and the smouldering fire sending out a dim, uncertain glow, the room was full of deep shadows.

Brantain sat in one of these shadows; it had overtaken him and he did not mind. The obscurity lent him courage to keep his eyes fastened as ardently as he liked upon the girl who sat in the firelight.

She was very handsome, with a certain fine, rich coloring that belongs to the healthy brune type. She was quite composed, as she idly stroked the satiny coat of the cat that lay curled in her lap, and she occasionally sent a slow glance into the shadow where her companion sat. They were talking low, of indifferent things which plainly were not the things that occupied their thoughts. She knew that he loved her—a frank, blustering fellow without guile enough to conceal his feelings, and no desire to do so. For two weeks past he had sought her society eagerly and persistently. She was confidently waiting for him to declare himself and she meant to accept him. The rather insignificant and unattractive Brantain was enormously rich; and she liked and required the entourage which wealth could give her.

During one of the pauses between their talk of the last tea and the next reception the door opened and a young man entered whom Brantain knew quite well. The girl turned her face toward him. A stride or two brought him to her side, and bending over her chair—before she could suspect his intention, for she did not realize that he had not seen her visitor—he pressed an ardent, lingering kiss upon her lips.

Brantain slowly arose; so did the girl arise, but quickly, and the newcomer stood between them, a little amusement and some defiance struggling with the confusion in his face.

“I believe,” stammered Brantain, “I see that I have stayed too long. I—I had no idea—that is, I must wish you goodby.”

He was clutching his hat with both hands, and probably did not perceive that she was extending her hand to him, her presence of mind had not completely deserted her; but she could not have trusted herself to speak.

“Hang me if I saw him sitting there, Nattie! I know it’s deuced awkward for you. But I hope you’ll forgive me this once—this very first break. Why, what’s the matter?”

“Don’t touch me; don’t come near me,” she returned angrily. “What do you mean by entering the house without ringing?”

“I came in with your brother, as I often do,” he answered coldly, in self-justification. “We came in the side way. He went upstairs and I came in here hoping to find you. The explanation is simple enough and ought to satisfy you that the misadventure was unavoidable. But do say that you forgive me, Nathalie,” he entreated, softening.

“Forgive you! You don’t know what you are talking about. Let me pass. It depends upon—a good deal whether I ever forgive you.”

At that next reception which she and Brantain had been talking about she approached the young man with a delicious frankness of manner when she saw him there.

“Will you let me speak to you a moment or two, Mr. Brantain?” she asked with an engaging but perturbed smile. He seemed extremely unhappy; but when she took his arm and walked away with him, seeking a retired corner, a ray of hope mingled with the almost comical misery of his expression. She was apparently very outspoken.

“Perhaps I should not have sought this interview, Mr. Brantain; but—but, oh, I have been very uncomfortable, almost miserable since that little encounter the other afternoon. When I thought how you might have misinterpreted it, and believed things”—hope was plainly gaining the ascendancy over misery in Brantain’s round, guileless face—“of course, I know it is nothing to you, but for my own sake I do want you to understand that Mr. Harvy is an intimate friend of long standing. Why, we have always been like cousins—like brother and sister, I may say. He is my brother’s most intimate associate and often fancies that he is entitled to the same privileges as the family. Oh, I know it is absurd, uncalled for, to tell you this; undignified even,” she was almost weeping, “but it makes so much difference to me what you think of—of me.” Her voice had grown very low and agitated. The misery had all disappeared from Brantain’s face.

“Then you do really care what I think, Miss Nathalie? May I call you Miss Nathalie?” They turned into a long, dim corridor that was lined on either side with tall, graceful plants.

They walked slowly to the very end of it. When they turned to retrace their steps Brantain’s face was radiant and hers was triumphant.

*   *   *
Harvy was among the guests at the wedding; and he sought her out in a rare moment when she stood alone. “Your husband,” he said, smiling, “has sent me over to kiss you.”
A quick blush suffused her face and round polished throat.

“I suppose it’s natural for a man to feel and act generously on an occasion of this kind. He tells me he doesn’t want his marriage to interrupt wholly that pleasant intimacy which has existed between you and me. I don’t know what you’ve been telling him,” with an insolent smile, “but he has sent me here to kiss you.”

She felt like a chess player who, by the clever handling of his pieces, sees the game taking the course intended. Her eyes were bright and tender with a smile as they glanced up into his; and her lips looked hungry for the kiss which they invited.

“But, you know,” he went on quietly, “I didn’t tell him so, it would have seemed ungrateful, but I can tell you. I’ve stopped kissing women; it’s dangerous.”

Well, she had Brantain and his million left. A person can’t have everything in this world; and it was a little unreasonable of her to expect it.

Originally published in the January 17, 1895, issue of Vogue.

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Critical Moments

Sadakichi Hartmann (1867–1944)
From American Flash Fiction: An Anthology

The Doctor (1891), oil on canvas by British artist Luke Fildes (1843–1927). Wikimedia Commons.
When Sadakichi Hartmann was seventeen years old and living with relatives in Philadelphia, a local bookseller impressed by the young man’s precocious familiarity with American poetry suggested that he meet with Walt Whitman. “He is living right across the river, in Camden, he likes to see all sorts of people,” the bookseller urged. Hartmann recounted his first visit, which occurred in November 1884:
An old man with a long grey beard, flowing over his open shirt front—the first thing I actually saw of Whitman was his naked breast—half opened the door and looked out.

Sadakichi: “I would like to see Walt Whitman.”

Whitman: “That’s my name. And you are a Japanese boy, are you not?” (Except very small boys the only person I met in those years who recognized my nationality at the first glance.)

Sadakichi: “My father is a German, but my mother was a Japanese and I was born in Japan.”

Whitman: “H'm—Come in.”
Hartmann’s visit would prove to be the first of many afternoons spent with the old poet during the next four years.

Carl Sadakichi Hartmann was born on Dejima, a man-made island off the coast of Nagasaki that for centuries had been the only Japanese territory open to Westerners. His Japanese mother died shortly after childbirth, and Sadakichi was sent to Germany by his father, a wealthy Prussian merchant, to be raised by his uncle and grandparents in Hamburg. When he was compelled to enroll in the imperial naval academy, Sadakichi rebelled and fled to Paris. His father cut him off financially and sent him to another branch of the family in Philadelphia. The fourteen-year-old arrived in June 1882 to live with an elderly couple that found him employment as an errand boy in a lithographic printing house specializing in cigar box labels.

Whitman was soon impressed by the teenager’s largely self-directed American education and reading: “I wish you could meet him,” he told his friend and assistant, Horace Traubel:
. . . his views on things Occidental, as they say, are rare, novel—should be heard. They come from one who has his roots in the other side of the planet—was raised under surprising differences of perspective. Take his ideas of Holland, France, Germany, England (he has been in all those countries) and you will find them very often just the things we need to have told us. Hartmann has written astonishingly good studies. His observations on America are bright—surprisingly searching—some of them.
On the ferry home after each of their talks, Hartmann would jot down what Whitman had said, and in April 1889 he collated quotations from their conversations for an article in the New York Herald. His transcriptions of Whitman’s unvarnished (and occasionally decontextualized) opinions about other living authors, including Oliver Wendell Holmes and the critic Edmund Clarence Stedman, proved controversial and embarrassing. Whitman privately expressed disappointment, and his inner circle of friends and devotees, including Traubel, denounced Hartmann for publishing a work they considered sensationalistic gossip and a violation of privacy. Nevertheless, Whitman and Hartman kept in touch and even met on a couple of occasions before Whitman’s death in 1892. Hartmann would expand his recollections into a short book, Conversations with Walt Whitman, which appeared in 1895.

During this period, Hartmann’s career had been branching off simultaneously in several directions: as an art critic, playwright, poet, and fiction writer. He prolifically wrote articles on the arts for newspapers in Boston and New York, and he founded and edited an influential journal, The Art Critic, which was “dedicated to the encouragement of American art.” During the 1890s he wrote four plays: Christ, Buddha, Confucius, and Mohammed. The first of the series attracted relatively little attention when it was published as a book in early 1893, but by the end of the year the Boston Record condemned its publication as heretical and launched a crusade against the author, resulting in his arrest on obscenity charges and the destruction of all unsold copies. Slapped with a fine of $100 and bankrupted by the cost of the books, Hartmann was forced to shut down The Art Critic after its third issue. Despite the scandal and its attendant notoriety, Hartmann became an American citizen in 1894.

He soon met the American photographer Alfred Stieglitz and wrote numerous articles for Stieglitz’s groundbreaking magazines Camera Notes and Camera Work. Hartmann’s most significant work, the two-volume History of American Art (1901), promoted the recognition of avant-garde art and artists. While all this was going on, Hartmann wrote his first works of fiction that are among the earliest short stories in English by an Asian American author—seven tales that he published at his own expense as Schopenhauer in the Air (1899). We present one of those tales below as our Story of the Week selection.

*   *   *
Notes: Hartmann dedicated his story to William Dean Howells (1837–1920), the American novelist and story writer, anthologist, magazine editor, critic, and champion of literary realism whose broad influence—and support for younger writers—had a substantial impact on the literature of his times. Matthias Grünewald (c. 1470–1528) was a German religious painter whose work rejected the classicism of Renaissance art. Czarda is a traditional Hungarian folk dance. In this story, agnus dei (Latin: Lamb of God, as Jesus is called by John the Baptist) refers to a medallion, typically made of wax, depicting a lamb and serving as a symbol of protection and faith..

*   *   *
For this week’s selection, we reproduce Hartmann’s story in its entirety below. You may also download it as a PDF or view it in Google Docs.

Critical Moments
(to W. D. Howells)

The door bell rang timidly as if avoiding unnecessary noise.

The mother, starting up from her dejection, ejaculated: “The doctor!” then in an ardent undertone: “Virgin Mary, save, oh save my child.”

The father made a gesture: “Now we will see,” and nodding complacently shuffled into the hall; he returned next moment with a spectacled young man, who by his nervous mien, assuming notwithstanding an air of importance, showed his inexperience.

He hastily opened his bag and stepped to the lounge where a little boy lay bedded among pillows and sheets: a long, narrow, emaciated form, like a figure drawn by Grünewald.

The kerosene lamp spread its spare light on the faded red cover on the table, leaving the rest of the sultry room in semi-darkness. A faint odor of perfumes seemed to lay on every object. The clock ticked offensively loud, telling with every second that a human life neared its end. A half-finished meal stood on the mantelpiece, its drapery moved sadly with every draught. Now and then the window panes trembled when the Elevated passed by.

The mother, with beating heart, busied herself in the adjoining kitchen, brewing some medicaments which her neighbor, a gossiping old maid had recommended to her.

The father, with lips slightly apart, stupid and helpless, as men generally are at such moments, stood behind the doctor.

The doctor at once felt the seriousness of the case, shrugged his shoulder and asked for the lamp. The father moved the table awkwardly to the bedside, and stared at the trembling shadows on the ceiling.

The doctor felt the child’s pulse, sitting down on the edge of the couch, whereby he upset a glass of water; he looked embarrassed at the carpet consuming the moisture, and forgot to count.

The father also glanced down with an expression which seemed to imply: “That doesn’t matter—but the child, it’s all over, isn’t it?”

The young doctor continued to count, moving his lips rapidly, then took the temperature, and felt the pulse again. It was his first case of the kind; at college he had always neglected children’s diseases—why bother with them if there are such things as female complaints in the world—and now in his anxiety he realized that he did not know any more than the parents about the ailment of his patient, whose breath was scarcely audible at times. He only felt that the child was very sick and probably would die under his hands. Why hadn’t he refused to come at this late hour.

Suddenly boisterous dance music and the noise of gliding footsteps interrupted the silence.

“What is that?” asked the spectacles. He still held the hand of his patient not knowing what to do, endeavoring in vain to remember something he had never known.

“The Hungarians upstairs celebrate a wedding.”

“My, how can they—I would—”

“They don’t care, they all have more children than they want.”

“That’s so,” smiled the doctor, “yes, yes, they come rather quick, don’t they—therefore one does not feel their loss—excuse me—I mean—”

“But this is our only one,” came plaintively from the kitchen.

“Oh, is it,” cold perspiration stood on his forehead. What should he say, surely he had to say something, and he desperately groped about in his bag.

Then it grew silent again in the little sick-room; above the floor shook with a droning sound under the stamping measures of a Czarda as far as it can be indulged in in a little flat.

The confused screaming of joy intermingling with the music that poured through the open windows, ablaze with light, into the otherwise so silent street, told all curious neighbors that the intoxication of wine and the senses had well intermingled, that at least in this flat there were people who believed they were happy.

“Well?” The mother came back from the kitchen, looking at the two men with an enquiring, imploring look.

The doctor, in despair at his ignorance, shook his perspiring head, with tears of shame in his eyes, which the good people took for sympathy.

She shaded the lamp with a newspaper, so that the light did not fall on the face of him whose birth had almost cost her life, in deep thought took up the little ten-cent china statue of the Virgin Mary and put it down again, then nodding her head in silent prayer, she sank down in a chair, her hands folded in her lap.

“What good will that do?” said the husband, almost roughly, drawing his underlip forward.

“Oh, God can not be so cruel to take him away from us.”

“Well, pray on and see if he will help us. Damn it, I wish he could!”

“I won’t believe in God any more if he takes him away from me.”

The husband paced softly up and down, now and then stopping to put things in order on the mantelpiece, or brushing with his hand one piece or another of his scant wardrobe hanging in a corner. He thought of the religious quarrels he had so often had with his wife, fierce quarrels, as they both were stupidly bigoted, he in his unbelief, she in her faith.

“Damn religion altogether! If the child would only live!” and he thrust his hands into the pockets of his pants. How much had he to pay that doctor, anyhow, who sat there so glum without saying a word. One dollar, two dollars, or even three dollars—he had only a five dollar bill, how could he change it in the meanwhile?

The doctor had a faint smile on his lips, ready to grin nervously at any moment, should they look at him.

The noise upstairs continued. It seemed the bride and bridegroom had left, and the remaining guests behaved more frantic than before. Why not! Such chances of enjoying ourselves at the expenses of others after all do not occur so often in life. And the young people, madly whirling about, grew intoxicated with each other’s presence, and in hungry silly flirtation realized a foretaste of the disenchantment of married life.

Below the cold hand of the dying child lay still in the trembling fingers of the doctor, who suddenly let it fall, and with unsteady eyes, and blanched face, motioned for more light.

The father mechanically seized the lamp and held it with a nerveless arm.

The mouth of his child lay open, a round black hole, the cheeks were hollow, a dark violet ring under the eyes, the white of which had turned a disagreeable bluish-yellow. The hair, without a trace of light, lay in lank strings around his face, and the shadow of his nose almost looked comical, the father held the light so low.

“Dead.”

“Dead!”

“Dead!” a frightful scream rang through the room, and drowned the noise above. Her fingers had groped tremblingly over the clammy body of her child.

She clenched her fists and bursting into ghastly laughter, tore the agnus dei from her breast and flung it into a corner.

The band upstairs struck up a maddening gallop.

“Come, let us be gay with the Hungarians,” and she sank sobbing to the ground. In this chaotic moment of dull piercing pain she had not only lost her child, but also her faith.

The father stood nodding in the middle of the room. “This had to come, but,—” there was a confusion of ideas in him; he wanted to say some word of consolation; he tried to express something, but could not, something of that we all feel in the critical moments of our life, but which we never utter, as our human language is insufficient. And as if he knew that only music could express such tumult and agony, he grunted a few inarticulate sounds . . . , ending with, “Well, we must bear it—but as the old woman said, this was our only one,” then he felt relieved; his greatest pain was over.

*   *   *
The young doctor had sneaked away without giving the father a chance to pay him. It was a sad experience; he might have died anyhow—yet a sting of conscience made him take up the neglected study, and to-day he is considered on the Eastside an expert on children’s diseases.

First published in Schopenhauer in the Air: Seven Stories (1899).

Sunday, October 25, 2026

The Men in the Storm

Stephen Crane (1871–1900)
From Stephen Crane: Prose & Poetry

Snow in New York [cropped], 1902, oil painting by American artist Robert Henri (1865–1929). National Gallery of Art.
A blizzard on the evening of February 26, 1894, buried New York City in twenty inches of snow, accompanied by gusts of more than forty miles per hour. The following morning, the artist Corwin Knapp Linson went to check up on his friend, Stephen Crane, who, flat broke, was crashing with three struggling young artists in a studio apartment on East 23rd Street. “I found Steve in bed in the old [Art Students] League Building looking haggard and almost ill,” Linson recalled a quarter century later in a memoir of his friendship with Crane. “All the others were out, getting ferocious appetites but little else. Pulling a manuscript from under his pillow, he tossed it to me and settled back under cover to watch.”

Crane had gone out during the storm to observe firsthand the direst conditions faced by New York’s homeless. He had been prompted by a suggestion to write about breadlines from Hamlin Garland, whose debut story collection, Many Travelled Roads (1891), had met with considerable success. Linson wondered if Garland “knew what it cost Steve in vital force to get that story; exposure in rags to that icy cold, standing in the pelting storm studying the men as they gathered in almost interminable succession—and no sleep until it was written. I had known that he was going out that night, and so was anxious to see how he had come through, but I hardly expected to find him so exhausted.”

“Why didn't you put on two or three more undershirts, Steve?” Linson asked the bedridden writer. And Crane responded, “How would I know how those poor devils felt if I was warm myself? Nit! Anyway, I didn't have the shirts, you mutt!”

At the time, Crane had nearly finished writing his novel The Red Badge of Courage and, although he would soon begin contributing regularly to the New York Press, the year ahead would prove to be a challenge while he struggled to attract a publisher for the book that would make him famous. After Garland read the essay that Crane had written the night of the blizzard, he forwarded it to Benjamin Orange Flower, the editor of The Arena, with a note suggesting that “the author is hungry.” Both the magazine and its book publishing arm had printed much of Garland’s early work, and Flower readily accepted Crane’s article and a second sketch. “The Men in the Storm” appeared in the October 1894 issue, which included the editor’s prediction that “the young writer belonging to the new school is likely to achieve in his own field something like the success Hamlin Garland has attained in his.”

Paul Auster, in his biography Burning Boy, contrasts Crane’s methods with those of modern-day reporters and notes how it differs from what we think of as journalism:
He simply planted himself among the men and watched what they did and listened to what they said. Then he went home and sat down to record his impressions as faithfully as he could. Not once while reading the article do we suspect Crane of embellishing what he saw or intentionally making anything up, but for all that I would hesitate to classify the article as a piece of reportage. It is a piece of writing, and as such it sits squarely inside the realm of Crane's literary work and deserves the same kind of scrutiny as his novels, stories, and poems. “Sketch” is the term he and his editors used, and it is a good term precisely because it is so hard to pin down, an ambiguous term for an ambiguous form of writing that falls somewhere between fact and fiction, or facts set down by using the methods of fiction or, if you will, a story that does not tell a story but presents a picture (a sketch) of something that has happened. . . .
Auster points out that Crane obviously felt that blending in the crowd without enough clothing would allow him “to understand to understand his subjects more intimately and lead to a more truthful account. . . . He was probably wrong, but who are we to question the enthusiasm of a twenty-two-year-old boy burning to test his will against the elements?”

Notes: A tarrier drills holes in rock to blast out railroad tunnels—often a job done by Irish immigrants in Crane’s time. Cheese that! is slang for “stop (or hide) what you’re doing,”

*   *   *

For this week’s selection, we depart from the usual format and reproduce the selection, in its entirety, below. You may also download it as a PDF or view it in Google Docs


The Men in the Storm

At about three o’clock of the February afternoon, the blizzard began to swirl great clouds of snow along the streets, sweeping it down from the roofs and up from the pavements until the faces of pedestrians tingled and burned as from a thousand needle-prickings. Those on the walks huddled their necks closely in the collars of their coats and went along stooping like a race of aged people. The drivers of vehicles hurried their horses furiously on their way. They were made more cruel by the exposure of their positions, aloft on high seats. The street cars, bound up-town, went slowly, the horses slipping and straining in the spongy brown mass that lay between the rails. The drivers, muffled to the eyes, stood erect and facing the wind, models of grim philosophy. Overhead the trains rumbled and roared, and the dark structure of the elevated railroad, stretching over the avenue, dripped little streams and drops of water upon the mud and snow beneath it.

All the clatter of the street was softened by the masses that lay upon the cobbles until, even to one who looked from a window, it became important music, a melody of life made necessary to the ear by the dreariness of the pitiless beat and sweep of the storm. Occasionally one could see black figures of men busily shovelling the white drifts from the walks. The sounds from their labor created new recollections of rural experiences which every man manages to have in a measure. Later, the immense windows of the shops became aglow with light, throwing great beams of orange and yellow upon the pavement. They were infinitely cheerful, yet in a way they accented the force and discomfort of the storm, and gave a meaning to the pace of the people and the vehicles, scores of pedestrians and drivers, wretched with cold faces, necks and feet, speeding for scores of unknown doors and entrances, scattering to an infinite variety of shelters, to places which the imagination made warm with the familiar colors of home.

There was an absolute expression of hot dinners in the pace of the people. If one dared to speculate upon the destination of those who came trooping, he lost himself in a maze of social calculations; he might fling a handful of sand and attempt to follow the flight of each particular grain. But as to the suggestion of hot dinners, he was in firm lines of thought, for it was upon every hurrying face. It is a matter of tradition; it is from the tales of childhood. It comes forth with every storm.

However, in a certain part of a dark West-side street, there was a collection of men to whom these things were as if they were not. In this street was located a charitable house where for five cents the homeless of the city could get a bed at night and, in the morning, coffee and bread.

During the afternoon of the storm, the whirling snows acted as drivers, as men with whips, and at half-past three, the walk before the closed doors of the house was covered with wanderers of the street, waiting. For some distance on either side of the place they could be seen lurking in doorways and behind projecting parts of buildings, gathering in close bunches in an effort to get warm. A covered wagon drawn up near the curb sheltered a dozen of them. Under the stairs that led to the elevated railway station, there were six or eight, their hands stuffed deep in their pockets, their shoulders stooped, jiggling their feet. Others always could be seen coming, a strange procession, some slouching along with the characteristic hopeless gait of professional strays, some coming with hesitating steps wearing the air of men to whom this sort of thing was new.

It was an afternoon of incredible length. The snow, blowing in twisting clouds, sought out the men in their meagre hiding-places and skilfully beat in among them, drenching their persons with showers of fine, stinging flakes. They crowded together, muttering, and fumbling in their pockets to get their red, inflamed wrists covered by the cloth.

Newcomers usually halted at one of the groups and addressed a question, perhaps much as a matter of form, “Is it open yet?” Those who had been waiting inclined to take the questioner seriously and become contemptuous. “No; do yeh think we’d be standin’ here?”

The gathering swelled in numbers steadily and persistently. One could always see them coming, trudging slowly through the storm.

Finally, the little snow plains in the street began to assume a leaden hue from the shadows of evening. The buildings up-reared gloomily save where various windows became brilliant figures of light that made shimmers and splashes of yellow on the snow. A street lamp on the curb struggled to illuminate, but it was reduced to impotent blindness by the swift gusts of sleet crusting its panes.

In this half-darkness, the men began to come from their shelter places and mass in front of the doors of charity. They were of all types, but the nationalities were mostly American, German and Irish. Many were strong, healthy, clear-skinned fellows with that stamp of countenance which is not frequently seen upon seekers after charity. There were men of undoubted patience, industry and temperance, who in time of ill-fortune, do not habitually turn to rail at the state of society, snarling at the arrogance of the rich and bemoaning the cowardice of the poor, but who at these times are apt to wear a sudden and singular meekness, as if they saw the world’s progress marching from them and were trying to perceive where they had failed, what they had lacked, to be thus vanquished in the race. Then there were others of the shifting, Bowery lodging-house element who were used to paying ten cents for a place to sleep, but who now came here because it was cheaper.

But they were all mixed in one mass so thoroughly that one could not have discerned the different elements but for the fact that the laboring men, for the most part, remained silent and impassive in the blizzard, their eyes fixed on the windows of the house, statues of patience.

The sidewalk soon became completely blocked by the bodies of the men. They pressed close to one another like sheep in a winter’s gale, keeping one another warm by the heat of their bodies. The snow came down upon this compressed group of men until, directly from above, it might have appeared like a heap of snow-covered merchandise, if it were not for the fact that the crowd swayed gently with a unanimous, rhythmical motion. It was wonderful to see how the snow lay upon the heads and shoulders of these men, in little ridges an inch thick perhaps in places, the flakes steadily adding drop and drop, precisely as they fall upon the unresisting grass of the fields. The feet of the men were all wet and cold and the wish to warm them accounted for the slow, gentle, rhythmical motion. Occasionally some man whose ears or nose tingled acutely from the cold winds would wriggle down until his head was protected by the shoulders of his companions.

There was a continuous murmuring discussion as to the probability of the doors being speedily opened. They persistently lifted their eyes toward the windows. One could hear little combats of opinion.

“There’s a light in th’ winder!”

“Naw; it’s a reflection f ’m across th’ way.”

“Well, didn’t I see ’em lite it?”

“You did?”

“I did!”

“Well, then, that settles it!”

As the time approached when they expected to be allowed to enter, the men crowded to the doors in an unspeakable crush, jamming and wedging in a way that it seemed would crack bones. They surged heavily against the building in a powerful wave of pushing shoulders. Once a rumor flitted among all the tossing heads.

“They can’t open th’ doors! Th’ fellers er smack up ag’in ’em.” Then a dull roar of rage came from the men on the outskirts; but all the time they strained and pushed until it appeared to be impossible for those that they cried out against to do anything but be crushed to pulp. “Ah, git away f ’m th’ door!” “Git outa that!”

“Throw ’em out!”

“Kill ’em!”

“Say, fellers, now, what th’ ’ell? Give ’em a chanct t’ open th’ door!”

“Yeh damned pigs, give ’em a chanct t’ open th’ door!”

Men in the outskirts of the crowd occasionally yelled when a boot-heel of one of frantic trampling feet crushed on their freezing extremities.

“Git off me feet, yeh clumsy tarrier!”

“Say, don’t stand on me feet! Walk on th’ ground!”

A man near the doors suddenly shouted: “O-o-oh! Le’ me out—le’ me out!” And another, a man of infinite valor, once twisted his head so as to half face those who were pushing behind him. “Quit yer shovin’, yeh ——” and he delivered a volley of the most powerful and singular invective straight into the faces of the men behind him. It was as if he was hammering the noses of them with curses of triple brass. His face, red with rage, could be seen; upon it, an expression of sublime disregard of consequences. But nobody cared to reply to his imprecations; it was too cold. Many of them snickered and all continued to push.

In occasional pauses of the crowd’s movement the men had opportunity to make jokes; usually grim things, and no doubt very uncouth. Nevertheless, they are notable—one does not expect to find the quality of humor in a heap of old clothes under a snowdrift.

The winds seemed to grow fiercer as time wore on. Some of the gusts of snow that came down on the close collection of heads cut like knives and needles, and the men huddled, and swore, not like dark assassins, but in a sort of an American fashion, grimly and desperately, it is true, but yet with a wondrous under-effect, indefinable and mystic, as if there was some kind of humor in this catastrophe, in this situation in a night of snow-laden winds.

Once, the window of the huge dry-goods shop across the street furnished material for a few moments of forgetfulness. In the brilliantly-lighted space appeared the figure of a man. He was rather stout and very well clothed. His whiskers were fashioned charmingly after those of the Prince of Wales. He stood in an attitude of magnificent reflection. He slowly stroked his moustache with a certain grandeur of manner, and looked down at the snow-encrusted mob. From below, there was denoted a supreme complacence in him. It seemed that the sight operated inversely, and enabled him to more clearly regard his own environment, delightful relatively.

One of the mob chanced to turn his head and perceive the figure in the window. “Hello, lookit ’is whiskers,” he said genially.

Many of the men turned then, and a shout went up. They called to him in all strange keys. They addressed him in every manner, from familiar and cordial greetings to carefully-worded advice concerning changes in his personal appearance. The man presently fled, and the mob chuckled ferociously like ogres who had just devoured something.

They turned then to serious business. Often they addressed the stolid front of the house.

“Oh, let us in fer Gawd’s sake!”

“Let us in or we’ll all drop dead!”

“Say, what’s th’ use o’ keepin’ all us poor Indians out in th’ cold?”

And always some one was saying, “Keep off me feet.”

The crushing of the crowd grew terrific toward the last. The men, in keen pain from the blasts, began almost to fight. With the pitiless whirl of snow upon them, the battle for shelter was going to the strong. It became known that the basement door at the foot of a little steep flight of stairs was the one to be opened, and they jostled and heaved in this direction like laboring fiends. One could hear them panting and groaning in their fierce exertion.

Usually some one in the front ranks was protesting to those in the rear: “O—o—ow! Oh, say, now, fellers, let up, will yeh? Do yeh wanta kill somebody?”

A policeman arrived and went into the midst of them, scolding and berating, occasionally threatening, but using no force but that of his hands and shoulders against these men who were only struggling to get in out of the storm. His decisive tones rang out sharply: “Stop that pushin’ back there! Come, boys, don’t push! Stop that! Here, you, quit yer shovin’! Cheese that!” When the door below was opened, a thick stream of men forced a way down the stairs, which were of an extraordinary narrowness and seemed only wide enough for one at a time. Yet they somehow went down almost three abreast. It was a difficult and painful operation. The crowd was like a turbulent water forcing itself through one tiny outlet. The men in the rear, excited by the success of the others, made frantic exertions, for it seemed that this large band would more than fill the quarters and that many would be left upon the pavements. It would be disastrous to be of the last, and accordingly men with the snow biting their faces, writhed and twisted with their might. One expected that from the tremendous pressure, the narrow passage to the basement door would be so choked and clogged with human limbs and bodies that movement would be impossible. Once indeed the crowd was forced to stop, and a cry went along that a man had been injured at the foot of the stairs. But presently the slow movement began again, and the policeman fought at the top of the flight to ease the pressure on those who were going down.

A reddish light from a window fell upon the faces of the men when they, in turn, arrived at the last three steps and were about to enter. One could then note a change of expression that had come over their features. As they thus stood upon the threshold of their hopes, they looked suddenly content and complacent. The fire had passed from their eyes and the snarl had vanished from their lips. The very force of the crowd in the rear, which had previously vexed them, was regarded from another point of view, for it now made it inevitable that they should go through the little doors into the place that was cheery and warm with light.

The tossing crowd on the sidewalk grew smaller and smaller. The snow beat with merciless persistence upon the bowed heads of those who waited. The wind drove it up from the pavements in frantic forms of winding white, and it seethed in circles about the huddled forms, passing in, one by one, three by three, out of the storm.

Originally published in the October 1894 issue of The Arena and reprinted in the British edition of the collection The Open Boat and Other Stories (1898).

Sunday, October 11, 2026

The Thin Red Leash

James Thurber (1894–1961)
From Thurber’s Dogs

James Thurber with his Scottish terrier Jeannie, the troublemaking subject of several pieces in Thurber’s Dogs. Courtesy of the Ohio State University Archive.
In June 1940, James Thurber underwent a cataract operation with the aim of slowing or halting the deterioration of his eyesight, which had been impaired since a childhood accident involving a toy bow and arrow. Four additional surgeries followed over the course of the next ten months, with the result that he was nearly blind the following spring. Emerging from a period of deep depression (what he later called “a five-year nervous crack-up”), he spent the summer on Martha’s Vineyard and, in August, he wrote to fellow New Yorker colleagues E. B. White and Katharine White—who were also the proud owners of Minnie, a dachshund. Thurber’s surprisingly cheerful and optimistic letter imagined a future that included a new home and lots of dogs:
We would, of course, love to have a Minnie puppy, and it breaks our hearts that we wouldn’t be just right for a dachshund just now. It has long been our dream to have six or eight variegated dogs when we buy our house in the country—a dachshund, a poodle, a water spaniel, etc.
By the time of his “crack-up” Thurber had become nationally famous for his drawings of dogs, as well as his essays and stories mocking the interactions between humans and their canine friends. His very first short story, “Josephine Has Her Day,” featuring a couple’s fraught relationship with a bull terrier, appeared in the Kansas City Star’s Sunday magazine in 1926. In the fall of that year, Thurber and his wife, Althea, moved to New York City, found a small apartment on the outskirts of the meatpacking district, and celebrated his first wages as a reporter for the New York Evening Post by purchasing a Scottish terrier. “Jeannie had no show points to speak of,” he later wrote. “Her jaw was skimpy, her haunches frail, her forelegs slightly bowed. She thought dimly, and her co-ordination was only fair.” Early in 1927, Thurber sold his first short piece to The New Yorker and soon accepted a position on the magazine’s staff; among the stories he published that year was “The Thin Red Leash,” a humorous tale about Jeannie (although Thurber thinly disguised her with a more whimsical name).

From the beginning, Jeannie caused the Thurbers—and especially James—no end of angst and embarrassment. While they were visiting family in Columbus, she escaped. It took several days to find her, and he returned to his job at The New Yorker two days late. Three decades later, when Thurber selected the best of his writings and drawings about dogs for a collection called Thurber’s Dogs, he included “The Thin Red Leash,” two subsequent stories about Jeannie’s escapades, and a new essay titled “In Defense of Dogs, Even, After a Fashion, Jeannie.”

According to biographer Harrison Kinney (and confirmed somewhat by Thurber’s Dogs), Thurber eventually became disenchanted with Scotties and came to prefer poodles, which he regarded as more intelligent. Yet in March 1928, despite Jeannie’s travails and challenges, he was still quite fond of the breed. When he sent a letter to his brother Robert, who was grief-stricken over the loss of a family dog, Thurber wrote:
I certainly felt badly about Muggs, on account of you and the rest, and the old dog himself. I know what it would mean to me if Jeannie passed out and we've only had her little over a year. When I lost her in Columbus I was nearly nuts. That's the hell of having a dog. . . .

*   *   *
For this week’s selection, we reproduce Thurber’s story in its entirety below. You may also download it as a PDF or view it in Google Docs.

The Thin Red Leash

It takes courage for a tall thin man to lead a tiny Scotch terrier pup on a smart red leash in our neighborhood, that region bounded roughly (and how!) by Hudson and West Streets, where the Village takes off its Windsor tie and dons its stevedore corduroys. Here men are guys and all dogs are part bull. Here “cute” apartments stand quivering like pioneers on the prairie edge.

The first day that I sallied forth with Black Watch III bounding tinily at the street end of the thin red leash, a cement finisher, one of the crowd that finds an esoteric pleasure in standing on the bleak corner of Hudson and Horatio Streets, sat down on the sidewalk and guffawed. There were hoots and whistles.

It was apparent that the staunch and plucky Scotch terrier breed was, to these uninitiated bulldog-lovers, the same as a Pekingese. But Black Watch must have his airing. So I continued to brave such witticisms as “Hey, fella, where’s the rest of it?” and—this from a huge steamfitter—“What d’y’ say me an’ you an’ the dog go somewheres and have tea?”

Once a dockworker demanded, in a tone indicating he would not take Black Watch III for an answer, “What’s that thing’s name?”

My courage failed me. “Mike,” I said, giving the leash a red-blooded jerk and cursing the Scotty. The whole affair was a challenge to my gumption. I had been scared to call my dog by its right name.

The gang was on hand in full force the next evening. One of them snapped enormous calloused fingers at Black Watch and he bounded away, leash and all, from my grasp.

“Black Watch!” I shouted—if you could call it shouting.

“What did y’ call that dog, fella?” demanded a man who, I think, blows through truck exhaust whistles to test them.

“Black Watch,” said I.

“What’s that mean?” he asked menacingly.

“It was a Scottish regiment wiped out at Ypres or somewhere,” I said, pronouncing it “Eeprr.”

“Wiped out where?” he snarled.

“Wiped out at Wipers,” I said.

“That’s better,” he said.

I again realized that I had shown the white feather. That night I took a solemn, if not fervent, oath to tell the next heavy-footed lout that flayed my dog to go to hell. The following evening the gang was more numerous than ever. A gigantic chap lunged forward at us. He had the build of a smokestack-wrecker.

“Psst!” he hissed. Black Watch held his ground.

“They’re scrappers, these dogs,” I protested amiably.

“What d’ they scrap—cockroaches?” asked another man, amid general laughter. I realized that now was the time to die. After all, there are certain slurs that you can’t take about your dog—gang or no gang. Just then a monstrous man, evidently a former Hudson Duster who lifts locomotives from track to track when the turntables are out of order, lounged out of a doorway.

“Whadda we got here?” he growled.

“Park Avenoo pooch,” sneered one gas-house gangster.

The train-lifter eyed Black Watch, who was wagging his tail in a most friendly manner.

“Scotty, ain’t it?” asked the train-lifter, producing a sack of scrap tobacco.

“Yeah,” I said, as easily as I could.

“Damn fine dogs, Scotties,” said the train-lifter. “You gotta good ’un there, when it puts on some age, scout. Hellcats in a fight, too, I mean. Seen one take the tonsils out of a Airedale one day.”

“Yeah?” asked the smokestack-wrecker.

“Yeah,” said the train-lifter.

“Yeah,” said I.

Several huge hands went down to pat a delighted shaggy head. There were no more catcalls or hoots. Black Watch III had been acquitted of Pomeranianism. We’re quite good friends now, Black Watch and the gang and I. They call him Blackie. I am grateful to a kind Fate that had given the train-lifter the chance, between carrying locomotives, to see a Scotty in action.

First appeared in The New Yorker (August 13, 1927). Revised and included in Thurber's Dogs (1955). Copyright © 1955 James Thurber. Reprinted by permission of Rosemary A. Thurber and the Barbara Hogenson Agency.

Sunday, September 27, 2026

The Black Dress

Dorothy West (1907–1998)
From American Flash Fiction: An Anthology

Dorothy West in her New York City apartment, c. 1935. (Radcliffe Institute, Harvard University)
One of the youngest of the Harlem Renaissance writers, Dorothy West was given the nickname “The Kid” by Langston Hughes, and she counted among her closest friends and peers Zora Neale Hurston, Countee Cullen, and Richard Wright. Yet she was largely regarded by literary historians and critics as a footnote to the era—until a chance encounter with Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis helped make her famous at the age of 88.

Onassis, a prominent editor at Doubleday, was charmed by the weekly columns in the Vineyard Gazette written by West, who had been on Martha’s Vineyard for more than half a century. West’s father, freed from slavery at the age of seven, had moved to Boston and had risen in status as the proprietor of one of the region’s largest fruit wholesalers. Like many Black families of their class, the Wests purchased a vacation getaway in Oak Bluff on the Vineyard, and in 1943 Dorothy moved permanently from New York City to what had been her family’s summer residence. There she lived, writing short stories twice a month for The New York Daily News until 1960, followed by her column in the Gazette.

Through a mutual friend, Onassis heard about West’s unfinished novel, which she had begun writing in the 1960s. The two women were introduced, and Onassis told West she would very much like to consider the finished book for publication. They subsequently spent several weekend afternoons in West’s home discussing, rearranging, and editing the manuscript into shape. “Those who visited Ms. West knew she had papers and books everywhere except the ottoman or rocker, where she sat,” recalls Bettye Foster Baker, a neighbor and fellow Gazette columnist. “And so Dorothy West worked on her edits with Jackie Onassis sitting on the floor and the rest is history.”

Promoted as West’s first book in forty-seven years, The Wedding appeared in February 1995 and became an instant best seller. Two years later hundreds of people, including then–First Lady Hillary Clinton, opera singer Jessye Norman, and Harvard professor Henry Louis Gates, Jr. attended an event celebrating West’s ninetieth birthday. A television adaptation of The Wedding, produced by Oprah Winfrey and starring Halle Berry, followed in February of 1998. Onassis, unfortunately, did not live long enough to see the book’s success, and West added the following dedication before it went to press: “In memory of my editor, Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis. Though there was never such a mismatched pair in appearance, we were perfect partners.”

West’s sudden triumph was a fitting end to a storied life. Three quarters of a century earlier, as West entered her teens, she sent short sketches and stories to the Boston Post—and several were published. She moved to New York in the mid-1920s and, when she was eighteen years old, her unpublished story, “The Typewriter,” tied with Zora Neale Hurston’s “Spunk” for second place in a writing contest sponsored by Opportunity magazine. West’s story was among the fifteen selected for The Best Short Stories of 1926, alongside Opportunity’s first-place entry, Arthur Huff Faucet’s “Symphonique,” as well as such stories as Ernest Hemingway’s “The Undefeated” and Ring Lardner’s “Travelogue.”

At the Opportunity awards dinner in April 1926, West met Hurston and the two women became friends. Still new to the city, she briefly stayed in Hurston’s apartment and later sublet it when the latter was in Florida doing anthropological research. Much like the fortunes of many of the Harlem Renaissance writers, Hurston’s literary career and reputation fizzled after the 1930s. “She became well known” years after her death, West reflected in a 1995 interview with the Los Angeles Times:
That’s why I say, I’m very lucky to be alive, . . . to be recognized, because so many other young people died—because they had tuberculosis, or you bought liquor and sometimes it wasn’t any good. Sometimes you died from it. So whenever we talk about the Harlem Renaissance, I’m always a bit moved. My voice is even choking now.
In 1934 West moved back to New York after a brief interlude acting in the touring company for the hit play Porgy. The Depression-era failure of the family business and the death of her father in his late 70s left her without a dependable means of support, and she resumed writing stories, including “The Black Dress,” which appeared in Opportunity and which we reprint below. That year she also founded and edited a new magazine, Challenge, which lasted three years before folding. She then worked for a couple of years as a welfare relief worker and was briefly employed by the Federal Writers’ Project. After returning to the Vineyard, she finished her first novel, The Living Is Easy, and it was published in 1948. As she recalled to the Los Angeles Times interviewer, her debut book was initially expected to be a lucrative and groundbreaking literary event:
The phone rang and [my agent] said to me, “Are you sitting down?” And I said, “Yes, I’m sitting down.” Dorothy, he said, a magazine well known across the country, The Ladies Home Journal, is taking your book and they’re going to give you what—I don’t remember what, but it was quite a sum of money for the book. And it was to be serialized. A month later, my agent called me, very disappointed. [The magazine was] afraid they would have canceled subscriptions. That was the end of that.
Although well received by critics, the book’s sales were modest, undercut somewhat by reduced publisher expectations after the loss of its magazine serialization. The Living Is Easy was reissued by The Feminist Press to much broader recognition in 1982.

The last surviving member of the Harlem Renaissance, West died in August 1998, three years after The Wedding unexpectedly made her a celebrity; over four hundred people attended the memorial service. Today, the Dorothy West home still stands on Myrtle Avenue, half a block north of Dorothy West Avenue, in Martha’s Vineyard.

*   *   *
For this week’s selection, we reproduce West’s story in its entirety below. You may also download it as a PDF or view it in Google Docs.

The Black Dress

They sent me word that morning that old Mr. Johnson had died in the night. It was not really a surprise to me. I knew he had been lingering for weeks.

That was my chiefest reason for writing to Margaret. Deep in his heart old Johnson, her father, loved her very much. It would not be so hard for him to go with her hand in his. Margaret I knew had forgiven him his early injustice. I felt she would be glad to brighten his last pain-black days. They would not be many. He could not live beyond the year, and it was Christmas week when I wrote her to come.

I did not mention her father’s hopeless illness. I simply asked her, for old times’ sake, to come and hang up her stocking with mine, as we had done when we were very young.

Her acceptance came in a day or two. She was between shows and husbands. It would be good to see me again after twelve long years. Did I still have dimples? Would I find her changed? For better, for worse?

I wondered. Margaret and I had been like sisters all our growing years. I suppose she loved me more than she loved anyone else. She had only an impatient tolerance for her bigoted father. But the years had probably softened this into something nearer affection. After all, he was her only living relative.

To my knowledge she never wrote him. Nor did she write me. Occasionally I would get a telegram of extravagant endearment, and very often a generous check. My babies, who had never seen her, spoke of her as Aunt Margaret.

I wrote her regularly. She had always seemed hard to the home folks, but I felt I understood her. She was not hard. She was simply unsentimental. She had one goal, the stage. She had had to fight the whole community, beginning with her father, to make them accept the theatre as a legitimate profession. The fight with her father had been long and bitter. The neighbors had taken his side. Naturally that did something to her spirit. When she left home at eighteen, it was not a girl but a bitter woman who said good-by to me, the only one to bid her good-by and God-speed.

I hoped the years had taken the edge off her bitterness. I always mentioned her father in my letters. Toward the last I would say he sent love. For old Johnson did love Margaret. And I am sure, on the lonely nights, he wished very much he could unsay the things that had sent her from him. Well, while there is life, it is not too late. At least he could say he was sorry he had said them. That was in my mind, knowing the time, his time, was so short, when I wrote to Margaret.

The hospital called me the morning of Christmas eve. They asked me the address of old Johnson’s nearest of kin. I gave them Margaret’s before I realized she would be in town that evening. After I hung up I hoped she had already left. For I could tell her more tenderly than a cold telegram.

Someone rang my bell. It was the boy with the tree my husband had bought on his way to work. The children were wild. And when I saw their excited faces, I suddenly and selfishly decided that I could not bring death into my house to mar the happiest day of their year.

No, Margaret must wait until tomorrow evening to be told. I would tell her after the last tired child had been tucked into bed. In the meantime I would make some arrangements with an undertaker.

I knew this was the most wicked thing I would ever do in my life. But, oh, she would understand when we stood and smiled down at the sleeping children that it would have been cruel to spoil their day with our grown-up grief.

Early that evening a taxi rolled up. A woman got out. I flew downstairs to open my door with words of gay greeting or solemn condolence ready on my lips. Margaret’s dear familiar face was radiant. She did not know. I held her fast in my arms.

I shall never forget our happy evening. She was like a sprite, never still. She fell in love with small Margaret. Once she said fiercely to the shining faces, “Be happy. Let nothing stand in the way of your being happy.” I thought, How hard her beautiful face is. It is only I who know she is not hard.

We were tired at last. Sentimentally we were going to sleep together. My husband was banished to a cot in the dining room, and sometime during the night he would fill our stockings.

Margaret and I were in my room together. She opened her bag to fetch out the stocking. On the top lay a black dress, looking as if it had been stuffed in hastily. I caught my breath sharply. She followed my glance.

She said indifferently, “This went in at the last moment. It’ll have to be pressed before I wear it.”

My throat went dry. For the first time in my life I was going to sleep with a stranger.

First published in the May 1934 issue of Opportunity: Journal of Negro Life.